17 Must-Try Homemade Steak Sauce Recipes That Will Amaze Your Taste Buds

Homemade Steak Sauce Recipes – If you’re a steak lover like me, then you know there’s nothing quite like a perfectly cooked ribeye, sirloin, or a thick, juicy tomahawk. But why settle for the usual when you can take your steak to the next level with these incredible steak sauce recipes?

Cooking steak at home not only gives you the freedom to experiment but also saves you money compared to dining out at a fancy steakhouse. And having a collection of homemade sauces in your culinary arsenal opens up a world of possibilities for enhancing the flavors of your favorite cuts of meat.

So, without further ado, let’s dive into these 17 tantalizing steak sauce recipes that will undoubtedly elevate your dining experience.

1. Blue Cheese Sauce for Steak


If you’re a fan of bold and zesty flavors, the blue cheese sauce will be right up your alley. Made with tangy blue cheese and complemented by the freshness of chives, this sauce adds a unique twist to your steak. While it goes well with almost anything, it truly shines when paired with a buttery, garlicky steak. The combination of flavors is simply divine. Of course, feel free to use this sauce on any dish that tickles your fancy, but trust me when I say that it complements decadent steaks like no other.

2. Béarnaise Sauce – The World’s Finest Steak Sauce

Many consider Béarnaise sauce, a luscious variation of Hollandaise sauce, to be one of the finest steak sauces in the world. The good news is that it’s much easier to make than you might think. In just 15 minutes or less, you can create a velvety sauce bursting with the flavors of tarragon, chervil, butter, white wine, and more. It’s a true indulgence for your taste buds.

3. Diane Sauce for Steak

If you’ve ever enjoyed a steak at a restaurant, you might have come across Diane sauce. It’s creamy, buttery, and herb-infused, adding a whole new level of depth to the flavor of your steak. This sauce is genuinely incredible; I’m not ashamed to admit that I’d happily clean my plate with a roll just to savor every last drop. And the best part? It only takes around 10 minutes to whip up.

4. Chimichurri Sauce for Steak

Prepare your taste buds for the bold and flavorful Chimichurri sauce. Made with parsley, oregano, olive oil, sea salt, ground pepper, white wine vinegar, minced garlic, and crushed red peppers, this sauce is a fragrant powerhouse. It’s a staple on the menus of steak houses worldwide, and for a good reason – the fresh, zingy flavors beautifully complement the richness of the steak. If you’re a fan of fresh herbs, this sauce will surely win you over.

5. Easy Creamy Pepper Sauce

When it comes to a creamy pepper sauce, it doesn’t get much better than this. Thin, yet delightfully smooth, it boasts a ton of peppery goodness. With hints of garlic, onion, and a touch of zest from the lemon juice, this sauce is a versatile companion that can enhance any dish. But there’s something special about pairing it with a juicy, smoky grilled steak.

6. Creamy Whisky Sauce

For those seeking a touch of warmth and earthiness in their steak sauce, look no further than the creamy whisky sauce. With its thick, gravy-like consistency and flavors of whisky, beef, and mustard, this sauce is a real winner. And don’t worry if you find it too thick – simply add a bit of warm water to achieve your desired consistency.

7. A1 Steak Sauce

Let’s start with the classic choice that needs no introduction – A1 steak sauce. There’s a reason it’s so popular, and if you’re a fan, why not try making your own? This recipe is surprisingly simple, requiring less than ten ingredients and just half an hour of your time. The best part? You can whip up a larger batch and store it for later, making sure to refrigerate it, of course.

8. Heinz 57

Next up is Heinz 57 sauce, the second most-used steak sauce that you’ve probably encountered. The great news is that making your own version is even easier than you might think. With just five ingredients – ketchup, Worcestershire sauce, mustard, lemon juice, and hot pepper sauce – and no cooking involved, you can have a delicious sauce ready in just five minutes.

9. Herb Garlic Butter for Steak

Sometimes, simplicity is key. That’s where herb garlic butter comes into play. With just three ingredients – garlic, butter, and parsley – and five minutes of your time, you can create a flavor-packed butter that takes your steak, potatoes, rolls, or veggies to new heights. Personally, I find this butter so delicious that I could eat it all on its own. Give it a try, and you’ll understand why.

10. Incredible Red Wine Sauce for Steak

For those who appreciate the rich complexities of red wine, this sauce is a must-try. With a combination of butter, shallots, Pinot Noir, and a mere 20 minutes of cooking time, you’ll have a red wine steak sauce that is wonderfully fragrant and full of bold, savory flavors. As an added bonus, you can enjoy the rest of the wine with your meal, creating a win-win situation.

11. Mushroom Sauce for Steak

Mushroom lovers, rejoice! This creamy mushroom sauce will satisfy your cravings in no time. While it does require a few more ingredients than some other options, it still comes together in just 15 minutes. The sauce boasts a velvety texture, with slices of tender baby bella (cremini) mushrooms adding a savory and earthy touch. It’s like A1 sauce, but elevated to a whole new level of deliciousness.

12. Arby’s Horsey Sauce

You may be familiar with Arby’s horsey sauce as a delightful condiment for their sandwiches, but did you know it also pairs wonderfully with steak? And the best part is that you can make your own version with just three ingredients. All you need is mayo, creamed horseradish, and a touch of sugar. This sauce adds a pleasant heat and spiciness to your steak without overpowering it or making it overly salty. If you’re looking for an extra zing, there’s another Arby’s copycat sauce recipe to try as well.

13. Low-Carb Caramelized Onion and Blue Cheese Steak Sauce

If caramelized onions make your heart sing, then this low-carb steak sauce is a dream come true. Don’t let the “low-carb” label fool you – this sauce is bursting with flavor. Featuring sweet Vidalia onions, blue and cream cheeses, Worcestershire sauce, salt, and pepper, it’s a combination that guarantees a delectable result. While it may require a bit of time and effort, the payoff is worth it when you experience one of the most tantalizing and visually stunning steak toppings ever.

14. Cowboy Butter Sauce

Cowboy butter sauce, also known as a fantastic steak dipping sauce, is a buttery, herby, zesty delight with a hint of spice. The best part? It takes just five minutes to whip up. Chances are, you already have all the necessary ingredients in your kitchen, making it a quick and easy way to enhance your steak experience.

15. Classic Gremolata Recipe

Transport yourself to Italy with the classic gremolata sauce. Bursting with bright and zesty flavors, this sauce showcases the freshness of parsley. Combined with lemon juice, zest, and garlic, it creates a tantalizing blend that adds a pop of freshness to any dish. While it may look a little unusual with its deep green color, don’t let that deter you. Give it a try, and you’ll be amazed by its incredible taste and irresistible aroma.

16. Awesome Sauce

Prepare to be wowed by the unique flavors of Awesome Sauce. This creamy white sauce boasts an intriguing Asian flair, with hints of cayenne pepper, paprika, and spicy brown mustard. It strikes the perfect balance between heat and creaminess, creating a truly addictive taste. Its velvety consistency and impeccable appearance make it a crowd-pleaser. As the name suggests, Awesome Sauce lives up to its reputation as a truly remarkable addition to your culinary repertoire.

17. “Oh My!” Steak Sauce

Prepare for a sauce that will leave you exclaiming, “Oh my!” This low-carb, keto-friendly, and gluten-free steak sauce is a culinary masterpiece. In just 15 minutes, you can create a rich and earthy flavor profile that combines herbs, shallots, Dijon mustard, and a hint of cayenne pepper. It strikes the perfect balance between zesty and spicy, delivering a burst of deliciousness with every bite. You won’t believe that a sauce this sensational can also be healthy.

So there you have it, 17 sensational steak sauce recipes that will take your dining experience to new heights. Whether you prefer the bold flavors of chimichurri or the creamy indulgence of Béarnaise, there’s a sauce on this list to satisfy every palate. Don’t limit yourself to basic seasonings when you can explore a world of taste sensations with these homemade steak sauces. Elevate your steak dinners and unlock a realm of culinary possibilities with these delicious recipes. Get ready to impress your family and friends with your newfound culinary expertise. Happy cooking!

Share This

You May Also Like

About the Author: Rachel Michaels

A food photographer and travel blogger from New York City. Rachel's interest in cooking and travel began during her study abroad program in Italy, where she fell in love with Italian cuisine. She now captures the beauty of food and travels through her photography and blog posts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *